Antennas Mono pole Vs Rubber Ducky

Antennas Mono pole Vs Rubber Ducky

Why use a mono pole whip instead of a rubber ducky? For your mesh radio either Meshtastic or Reticulum
That’s an involved question. I’ll do my best to answer.
Short answer is it depends.
If you’re looking for maximum radio to radio distances not properly utilizing the mesh networking capabilities then you want a whip. If you are properly utilizing the mesh networking capabilities then you should use what ever antenna you feel like.

So we have to back up a bit. With mesh networking capabilities you don’t need to be able to make a transmission from 100km away. You can make short hops and therefore can reduce transmission power for a smaller RF footprint.

But if you don’t have many friends/teammates/hunting partners, then there is a chance that you need to be able to reach further between nodes.

Hope that makes sense.

So our recommendation is to understand your need first. Then select the antenna after you understand how you want the network to operate.

Let’s look at it from a potential real world situation:

You have 5 “hunting” partners. All 5 have a radio. You have a base station at camp and a Mobil node mounted in a vehicle.
That’s 7 total radios for your mesh.
You’re going to want a high gain, high elevation antenna on both the base station and the vehicular mounted radios.
If all 5 “hunters” are in reasonably close proximity to each other (within a couple miles) then having a small antenna like a rubber ducky on 4 radios and one member of the team has a larger antenna you would have a very capable network going.

On the other hand lets look at it from a much smaller perspective:

You are out scouting for "Deer" alone. You need to be able to relay critical information to home base (AKA wife). In this situation you have one base station node at base, one node on your person, and one vehicle mounted node on your truck. 3 total nodes/radios.

You would want as much ability to reach maximum distances as possible as you have a significantly smaller network, thus you will need to reach further between nodes/Radios. So in this case, you would want large high mounted antennas on your home base/Vehicle, and a good whip antenna on your hand held node/radio.

Check out our other blog posts about radios and mesh networking. Here

Check out our mesh network Node/Radios
Check out our line of Maximus antennas